Overall evaluation of economic theories

Richard Steinberg1
1Department of Economics, 516 Cavanagh Hall, IUPUI, Indianapolis

Tóm tắt

This article evaluates economic theories of the non-profit sector by their ability to enlighten our understanding of the scope of inquiry, the determinants of the size and scope of the non-profit sector, and the behavioural responses of donors, volunteers, paid staff and non-profit organisations to changes in their external environment. Adherence to a non-distribution constraint has proven to be a useful way of delimiting economic analysis of non-profit organisations, but more attention should be paid to alternatives. Economists have been less successful at developing usable distinctions between voluntary action and exchange. The size and scope of the sector appear to be determined by entrepreneurial supply factors, donations (which in turn are influenced by tax policy, governmental spending, fund-raising, and the quality and mixture of organisational outputs, commercial or charitable), commercial activities, capital supply, the supply of labour (paid and volunteered), the marketability of outputs, and the distribution of consumer characteristics. Variations of James's (1983) model have proven useful to predict the reaction of non-profits to exogenous changes.

Tài liệu tham khảo

Andreoni, J. (1988). Why free ride? Strategies and learning in public goods experiments,Journal of Public Economics, 35, 291–304. Andreoni, J. (1989) Giving with impure altruism: applications to charity and Ricardian equivalence,Journal of Political Economy, 97, 6, 1447–58. Andreoni, J. (1993) An experimental test of the public goods crowding-out hypothesis,American Economic Review, 83, 1317–27. Arrow, K.J. (1974) Gifts and exchanges,Philosophy and Public Affairs, 1, 343–62. Austen-Smith, D. and Jenkins, S. (1985) A multiperiod model of nonprofit enterprise,Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 32, 119–34. Auten, G.E. and Rudney, G. (1990) The variability of individual charitable giving in the US,Voluntas, 1, 2, 80–97. Auten, G.E., Cilke, J.M. and Randolph, W.C. (1992) The effects of tax reform on charitable contributions,National Tax Journal, 45, 267–90. Bagnoli, M. and McKee, M. (1991) Voluntary contribution games: efficient private provision of public goods,Economic Inquiry, 29, 351–66. Barrett, K.S. (1991) Panel-data estimates of charitable giving: a synthesis of techniques,National Tax Journal, 44, 365–81. Barrett, K.S. and McGuirk, A. (1992) Charitable giving and federal income tax policy. Additional evidence based on panel-data elasticity estimates: the case of the student's T distribution. Paper presented at 1992 annual conference of the Association for Research on Nonprofit Organizations and Voluntary Action, New Haven, Connecticut. Barrett, K., McGuirk, A. and Steinberg, R. (1997) Further evidence on the dynamic effects of taxes on giving,National Tax Journal, 50, 2, forthcoming. Becker, E. and Lindsay, C.M. (1994) Does the government free ride?Journal of Law and Economics, 37, 1, 277–96. Ben-Ner, A. (1986) Nonprofit organizations: why do they exist in market economies?, in S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.)The Economics of Nonprofit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York. Ben-Ner, A. (1987) Birth, change, and bureaucratization in nonprofit organizations: an economic analysis, Working paper, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota. Ben-Ner, A. and Van Hoomissen, T. (1991) Nonprofits in the mixed economy: a demand and supply analysis,Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 62, 519–50. Billis, D. (1993)Organising Public and Voluntary Agencies, Routledge, London. Bilodeau, M. and Slivinski, A. (1995a) Rational nonprofit entrepreneurship, Working paper, University of Western Ontario, Department of Economics, London, Ontario. Bilodeau, M. and Slivinski, A. (1995b) Rival nonprofit firms, Working paper, University of Western Ontario, Department of Economics, London, Ontario. Bilodeau, M. and Slivinski, A. (1995c) Profitable nonprofit firms, Paper presented at ARNOVA annual conference, Cleveland, Ohio. Borjas, G.J., Frech III, H.E. and Ginsburg, P.B. (1983) Property rights and wages: the case of nursing homes,Journal of Human Resources, 17, 231–46. Boulding, K. (1972)Towards a Pure Theory of Foundations, Nonprofit Report, New York. Bradley, R. and McClelland, R. (1997) A robust estimation of the effects of taxation on charitable contributions, Bureau of Labor Statistics. Bristol, R.B. (1985) Tax cuts and charitable giving,Tax Notes, 15 July, 323–6. Brown, E. and Lankford, R.H. (1992) Gifts of money and gifts of time: estimating the effects of tax prices and available time,Journal of Public Economics, 47, 321. Chang, C.F. and Tuckman, H.P. (1990) Do higher tax rates increase the market share of nonprofit hospitals?National Tax Journal, 43, 175–87. Chang, C.F. and Tuckman, H.P. (1991a) A methodology for measuring the financial vulnerability of charitable nonprofit organizations,Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 20, 445–60. Chang, C.F. and Tuckman, H.P. (1991b) Financial vulnerability and attrition as measures of nonprofit performance,Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 62, 4, 655–72. Chillemi, O. and Gui, B. (1990) Product quality in trust type nonprofits: an expository evaluation of three economic models, inTowards the 21st Century: Challenges for the Voluntary Sector (Proceedings of the 1990 AVAS Conference). London. Chillemi, O. and Gui, B. (1991) Uninformed customers and nonprofit organization: modelling ‘contract failure’ theory,Economics Letters, 35, 5–8. Clotfelter, C.T. (1985)Federal Tax Policy and Charitable Giving, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois. Coase, R.H. (1937) The nature of the firm,Economica, 386–405. Collard, D. (1978)Altruism and Economy. A Study in Non-Selfish Economics, Oxford University Press, Oxford. Colliton, J.W. (1980) The meaning of ‘contribution or gift’ for charitable contribution deduction purposes,Ohio State Law Journal, 41. Colombo, J.D. and Hall, M.A. (1995)The Charitable Tax Exemption, Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado. Conrad, D. (1986) Returns on equity for not-for-profit hospitals: a commentary and elaboration,Health Services Research, 21, 17–20. Cornes, R. and Sandler, T. (1984) Easy riders, joint production, and public goods,Economic Journal, 94, 580–98. Davie, B.F. (1985) Tax rate changes and charitable contributions.Tax Notes, 11 March, 1037–40. Davis, D.D. and Holt, C.A. (1992)Experimental Economics, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. Day, K.M. and Devlin, R.A. (1996) Volunteerism and crowding out: Canadian econometric evidence,Canadian Journal of Economics, 29, 1, 37–53. Doyle, M.P. (1992) New evidence on private charity: accounting for the effect of religious affiliation, Working paper, Department of Economics, MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Duncombe, W. and Brudney, J. (1992) Volunteer demand and the optimal mix of volunteer and paid staff in local governments, Paper presented at the annual ARNOVA conference, New Haven, Connecticut. Easley, D. and O'Hara, M. (1983) The economic role of nonprofit firms,Bell Journal of Economics, 14, 3, 531–38. Eckel, C.C. and Steinberg, R. (1993) Competition, performance and public policy towards nonprofits, in D.C. Hammack and D.R. Young (eds)Nonprofit Organizations in a Market Economy: Understanding New Roles, Issues, and Trends, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, California. Eckel, C.C. and Steinberg, R. (1994) Tax policy and the objectives of nonprofit organizations in a mixed-sector duopoly, Working paper, Indiana University Center on Philanthropy, Indianapolis, Indiana. Feigenbaum, S. (1980) The case of income redistribution: a theory of government and private provision of collective goods,Public Finance Quarterly, 8, 3–22. Feldstein, M. (1971) Hospital cost inflation: a study in nonprofit price dynamics,American Economic Review, 61, 853–872. Ferris, J. and Graddy, E. (1991) Production costs, transaction costs, and local government contractor choice,Economic Inquiry, 29, 541–54. Folland, S. (1990) Nonprofit entry: a theory and an empirical test for the case of hospitals, Working paper, School of Business Administration, Oakland University, Oakland, Minnesota. Frischmann, P.J. and Lin, S. (1990) Fixed and random effects models: two methods to improve parameter estimates using panel data, Working paper, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona. Goddeeris, J. (1988) Compensating differentials and self-selection: an application to lawyers,Journal of Political Economy, 96, 411–28. Goodspeed, T. and Kenyon, D. (1994) The nonprofit sector's capital constraint: does it provide a rationale for the tax-exemption granted to nonprofit firms?Public Finance Quarterly, 22. Grønbjerg, K. (1990) Managing nonprofit funding relationships: case studies of six human service organizations, Working paper 156, Program on Nonprofit Organizations, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut. Grønbjerg, K. (1993)Understanding Nonprofit Funding, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, California. Gui, B. (1990) Nonprofit organizations and product quality under asymmetric information, Working paper, Department of Economics and Statistics, Trieste University, Trieste, Italy. Gulley, O.D. and Santerre, R.E. (1993) The effect of tax exemption on the market share of nonprofit hospitals,National Tax Journal, 46, 477–86. Guttman, J.M. (1986) Matching behavior and collective action: some experimental evidence,Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 7, 171–98. Handy, F. (1995) Co-existence of nonprofits, for-profits and public sector institutions. Paper presented at 1995 ARNOVA conference, Cleveland, Ohio. Hansmann, H. (1980) The role of nonprofit enterprise,Yale Law Journal, 89, 3, 835–901. Hansmann, H. (1981a) Nonprofit enterprise in the performing arts,Bell Journal of Economics, 12, 341–61. Hansmann, H. (1981b) The rationale for exempting nonprofit organizations from the corporate income tax,Yale Law Journal, 91, 54–100. Hansmann, H. (1981c) Reforming nonprofit corporation law,University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 129, 497–623. Hansmann, H. (1987a) The effect of tax exemption and other factors on the market share of nonprofit versus for-profit firms,National Tax Journal, 40, 71–82. Hansmann, H. (1987b) Economic theories of nonprofit organization, in W.W. Powell (ed.)The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, Yale University Press, New Haven, Connecticut. Hansmann, H. (1990) Why do universities have endowments?,Journal of Legal Studies, 19, 3–42. Hey, J.D. (1991)Experiments in Economics, Basil Blackwell, Cambridge. Hirth, R.A. (1995) Consumer information and ownership in the nursing home industry, Working paper, University of Michigan, Department of Economics, Ann Arbor, Michigan. Holtmann, A.G. (1983) A theory of non-profit firms,Economica, 50, 439–49. Holtmann, A.G. and Ullmann, S.G. (1991) Transaction costs, uncertainty, and not-for-profit organizations: the case of nursing homes,Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 62, 4. Isaac, R.M. and Walker, J.M. (1988) Group size effects in public good provision: the voluntary contributions mechanism,Quarterly Journal of Economics, 53, 179–200. Jacobs, P. and Wilder, R.P. (1984) Pricing behavior of non-profit agencies: the case of blood products,Journal of Health Economics, 3, 49–61. James, E. (1983) How nonprofits grow: a model,Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 2, 350–66. James, E. (1986) Comment, in S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.)The Economics of Nonprofit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York. James, E. (1989) Introduction, in E. James (ed.)The Nonprofit Sector in International Perspective: Studies in Comparative Culture and Policy, Oxford University Press, New York. Kaufman, D.A. (1991) Self-serving philanthropy and pareto optimality,Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 62, 4, 573–90. Khanna, J., Posnett, J. and Sandler, T. (1995) Charity donations in the UK: new evidence based on panel data,Journal of Public Economics, 56, 2, 257–72. Kiesling, L.L. (1995) Moral sentiments and reputation capital in charitable giving: institutional change and the role of information in Victorian Lancashire, Working paper, Department of Economics, College of William and Mary, Williamsburg, Virginia. Kingma, B.R. (1993) Portfolio theory and nonprofit financial stability,Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 22, 105–20. Kingma, B.R. (1995) Do profits ‘crowd out’ donations, or vice versa? The impact of revenues from sales on donations to local chapters of the American Red Cross,Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 6, 21–38. Kingma, B.R. and McClelland, R. (1995) Public radio stations are really, really not public goods: charitable contributions and impure altruism,Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 66, 1, 65–76. Krashinsky, M. (1986) Transactions costs and a theory of the nonprofit organization, in S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.)The Economics of Nonprofit Institutions, Oxford University Press, New York. Lankford, R.H. and Wyckoff, J.H. (1991) Modeling charitable giving using a Box-Cox standard tobit model,The Review of Economics and Statistics, 73, 460–70. Ledyard, J.O. (1995) Public goods: a survey of experimental research, in J.H. Kagel and A.E. Roth (eds)The Handbook of Experimental Economics, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. Leete, L. (1994) The nonprofit wage differential in the US: new estimates from the 1990 Census, Working paper, Mandel Center for Nonprofit Organizations, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio. Lindahl, W.E. (1991) Differentiating planned and major gift prospects,American Prospect Research Association, Fall. Lindahl, W.E. (1995) The major gift donor relationship: an analysis of donors and contributions,Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 5, 411–32. Lindahl, W.E. and Winship, C. (1992) Predictive models for annual fundraising and major gift fundraising,Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 3, 43–64. Lindahl, W.E. and Winship, C. (1994) A logit model with interactions for predicting major gift donors,Research in Higher Education, 35, 729–43. McClelland, R. and Kokoski, M. (1994) Econometric issues in the analysis of charitable giving,Public Finance Quarterly, 22, 498–517. McGregor-Lowndes, M. (1992) Comparative legal structures of nonprofit organisations, Paper presented at Third International Conference on Philanthropy, Indianapolis, Indiana. Margolis, H. (1982)Selfishness, Altruism, and Rationality, Cambridge University Press, New York. Mark, M.M. and Shotland, R.L. (1983) Increasing charitable contributions: an experimental evaluation of the American Cancer Society's recommended solicitation procedures,Journal of Voluntary Action Research, 12, 2, 8–22. Marks, M. (1993) The effect of alternative rebate rules and preference strength in the provision point mechanism of voluntary contributions: an experimental investigation, unpublished Ph.D. dissertation in Economics, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas. Marwell, G. and Ames, R.E. (1980) Experiments on the provision of public goods II: Provision points, stakes, experience, and the free-rider problem,American Journal of Sociology, 85, 927–37. Marwell, G. and Ames, R.E. (1981) Economists free ride: does anyone else?Journal of Public Economics, 15, 295–310. Mauser, E. (1993) Is organizational form important to consumers and managers: an application to the day-care industry, unpublished Ph.D. dissertation in Economics, University of Wisconsin at Madison Madison, Wisconsin. Menchik, P. and Weisbrod, B. (1987) Volunteer labor supply,Journal of Public Economics, 32, 159–83. Mohr, J. (1995) The impact of state intervention in the nonprofit sector: the case of the new deal, Paper presented at ARNOVA annual conference, Cleveland, Ohio. Morgan, J. and Sefton, M. (1996) Funding public goods with lotteries: an experiment, Working paper, Pennsylvania State University, Department of Economics, State College, Pennsylvania. Mueller, M. (1975) Economic determinants of volunteer work by women,Signs: Journal of Women and Culture in Society, 1, 325–88. Newhouse, J.P. (1970) Toward a theory of nonprofit institutions: an economic model of a hospital,American Economic Review, 60, 2, 64–73. Okunade, A. (1994) Determinants of charitable giving of business school alumni, Working paper, Department of Economics, Memphis University, Memphis, Tennessee. Okunade, A., Wunnava, P.V. and Walsh Jr., R. (1994) Charitable giving of alumni: microdata evidence from a large public university,The American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 53, 73–84. O'Neil, C.J., Steinberg, R. and Thompson, G.R. (1996) Reassessing the tax-favored status of the charitable deduction for gifts of appreciated assets,National Tax Journal, 49, 2, 215–34. Oster, S.M. (1992) Nonprofit organizations as franchise operations,Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 2, 3, 223–38. Pauly, M. (1987) Paying a return on equity to not-for-profit hospitals-some further thoughts,Health Services Research, 22, 2, 271–5. Posnett, J. and Sandler, T. (1986) Joint supply and the finance of charitable activity,Public Finance Quarterly, 14, 209–22. Posnett, J. and Sandler, T. (1989) Demand for charity donations in private non-profit markets: the case of the UK,Journal of Public Economics, 40, 2, 187–200. Preston, A.E. (1988a) The nonprofit firm: a potential solution to inherent market failures,Economic Inquiry, 26, 493–506. Preston, A.E. (1988b) The effects of property rights on labor costs of nonprofit firms: an application to the day care industry,Journal of Industrial Economics, 36, 337–49. Preston, A.E. (1989) The nonprofit worker in a for-profit world,Journal of Labor Economics, 7, 4, 438–63. Preston, A.E. (1992) Entrepreneurial self-selection into the nonprofit sector: effects on motivations and efficiency, Working paper, W. Averell Harriman School for Management and Policy, SUNY at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, New York. Randolph, W.C. (1995) Dynamic income, progressive taxes, and the timing of charitable contributions,Journal of Political Economy, 103, 4, 709–38. Rawls, J., Ullrich, R. and Nelson Jr. O. (1975) A comparison of managers entering or reentering the profit and nonprofit sectors,Academy of Management Journal, 18, 616–23. Ribar, D.C. and Wilhelm, M.O. (1995) Charitable contributions to international relief and development,National Tax Journal, 48, 2, 229–44. Ricketts, R.C. and Westfall, P.H. (1993) New evidence on the price elasticity of charitable contributions,Journal of the American Taxation Association, 15, 1–25. Roomkin, M. and Weisbrod, B. (1994) Managerial compensation in for-profit and nonprofit hospitals: is there a difference? Working paper, Center for Urban Affairs and Policy Research, Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois. Rose-Ackerman, S. (1981) Do government grants to charity reduce private donations?, in M. White (ed.)Nonprofit Firms in a Three-Sector Economy, The Urban Institute, Washington, DC. Rose-Ackerman, S. (1987) Ideals versus dollars: donors, charity managers, and government grants,Journal of Political Economy, 95, 4, 810–23. Salamon, L.M. (1987) Of market failure, voluntary failure, and third-party government: toward a theory of government-nonprofit relations in the modern welfare state,Journal of Voluntary Action Research, 16, 29–49. Salamon, L.M. and Anheier, H.K. (1992) In search of the nonprofit sector: the question of definitions,Voluntas, 3, 2, 125–52. Samuelson, P. (1947)Foundations of Economic Analysis, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Schiff, J. (1985) Does government spending crowd out charitable contributions?,National Tax Journal, 38, 535–46. Schiff, J. (1990)Charitable giving and Government Policy: An Economic Analysis, Greenwood Press, Westport, Connecticut. Schiff, J. and Steinberg, R. (1988) The effect of federal government expenditure cutbacks on service provision by states and nonprofit organizations, Working paper, Department of Economics, Virginia Polytechnic Institute & State University, Blacksburg, Virginia. Schiff, J. and Weisbrod, B. (1991) Competition between for-profit and nonprofit organizations in commercial markets,Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 62, 4, 619–40. Schlesinger, M. (1985) Economic models of nonprofit organizations: a reappraisal of the property rights approach, Working paper, JFK School, Harvard University. Sefton, M. and Steinberg, R. (1996) Reward structures in public goods experiments,Journal of Public Economics, 58, 263–87. Spiegel, M. (1995) Charity without altruism,Economic Inquiry, 33, 4, 625–40. Steinberg, R. (1986) Should donors care about fund raising?, in S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.)The Economics of Nonprofit Institutions: Studies in Structure and Policy. Oxford University Press, New York. Steinberg, R. (1987a) Voluntary donations and public expenditures in a federalist system,American Economic Review, 77, 24–36. Steinberg, R. (1987b) Nonprofit organisations and the market, in W.W. Powell (ed.)The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, Yale University Press, New Haven, Connecticut. Steinberg, R. (1990a) Profits and incentive compensation in nonprofit firms,Nonprofit Management and Leadership 1, 2, 137–51. Steinberg, R. (1990b) Taxes and giving: new findings,Voluntas, 1, 2, 61–79. Steinberg, R. (1991a) Does government spending crowd out donations? Interpreting the evidence,Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 62, 4, 591–618. Steinberg, R. (1991b) The economics of fundraising, in D. Burlingame and M. Hulse (eds)Taking Fund Raising Seriously, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, California. Steinberg, R. (1993) Public policy and the performance of nonprofit organizations: a general framework,Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 22, 1, 13–32. Steinberg, R. (1994) United Cancer Council v. Commissioner of the IRS and the indirect regulation of fundraising, Working paper, Indiana University Center on Philanthropy, Indianapolis, Indiana. Steinberg, R. (1995) What the numbers say,Advancing Philanthropy, 3, 2, 26–31. Steinberg, R. and Eckel, C.C. (1995) A deeper look at the tax preferences given nonprofit organizations, Working paper, Indiana University Center on Philanthropy, Indianapolis, Indiana. Steinberg, R. and Gray, B.H. (1993) ‘The role of nonprofit enterprise’ in 1992: Hansmann revisited,Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 22, 297–316. Steinberg, R. and Weisbrod, B.A. (1996) To give or to sell? That is the question: or, … price discrimination by nonprofit organizations with distributional objectives, Working paper, Indiana University Center on Philanthropy, Indianapolis, Indiana. Steinwald, B. and Neuhauser, D. (1970) The role of the proprietary hospital,Law and Contemporary Problems, 35, 817–38. Toolson, R.B. (1990) The charitable contribution deduction: new evidence of a strong incentive effect,Advances in Taxation, 2, 107–29. Tuckman, H.P. and Chang, C.F. (1992) Nonprofit equity: a behavioral model and its policy implications,Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 11, 1, 76–87. Tullock, G. (1966) Information without profit,Papers on Non-Market Decisionmaking, 1, 141–59. Weisbrod, B.A. (1975) Toward a theory of the voluntary nonprofit sector in a three-sector economy, in E.S. Phelps (ed.)Altruism, Morality and Economic Theory, Russell Sage Foundation, New York. Weisbrod, B.A. (1983) Non-profit and proprietary sector behavior: wage differentials among lawyers,Journal of Labor Economics, 1, 3, 246–63. Weisbrod, B.A. (1988)The Nonprofit Economy, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Weisbrod, B.A. and Schlesinger, M. (1986) Public, private, nonprofit ownership and the response to asymmetric information: the case of nursing homes, in S. Rose-Ackerman (ed.)The Nonprofit Sector: Economic Theory and Public Policy. Oxford University Press, Fairlawn, New Jersey. Winkle, C. (1990) Supply-side theory of the role of the nonprofit sector: an analysis of two case studies, Working paper, School of Urban Planning and Policy, University of Illinois-Chicago, Chicago, Illinois. Wolff, N., Weisbrod, B. and Bird, E. (1993) The supply of volunteer labor: the case of hospitals,Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 4, 1, 23–46. Wolpert, J. (1977) Social income and the voluntary sector,Papers, Regional Science Association, 39, 217–29. Yamauchi, N. (1994) Taxation and charitable contributions in Japan, Paper presented at ISTR biennial conference, Pecs, Hungary. Young, D.R. (1983)If Not For Profit, For What?, DC Heath, Lexington, Massachusetts. Young, D.R. (1989) Local autonomy in afranchise age: structural change in national voluntary associations,Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 18, 101–17. Young, D.R. and Steinberg, R. (1995)Economics for Nonprofit Managers, The Foundation Center Press, New York. Young, D.R., Standley, A.P. and Hiedemann, S. (1995) Structural variation and change in national nonprofit associations: case studies in social services and health charities, Paper presented at the 1995 ARNOVA conference, Cleveland Ohio. Ziliak, S.T. (1996) The contradiction of compassion: private charity and the ‘solution’ to dependence. Paper presented at the Allied Social Science Association Meetings, San Francisco, California.