Equity in health insurance schemes enrollment in low and middle-income countries: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Tóm tắt
Ensuring access to essential quality health services and reducing financial hardship for all individuals regardless of their ability to pay are the main goals of universal health coverage. Various health insurance schemes have been recently implemented in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) to achieve both of these objectives. We systematically reviewed all available literature to assess the extent to which current health insurance schemes truly reach the poor and underserved populations in LMICs. In the systematic review, we searched on PubMed, Web of Science, EconLit and Google Scholar to identify eligible studies which captured health insurance enrollment information in LMICs from 2010 up to September 2019. Two authors independently selected studies, extracted data, and appraised included studies. The primary outcome of interest was health insurance enrollment of the most vulnerable populations relative to enrollment of the best-off subgroups. We classified households both with respect to their highest educational attainment and their relative wealth and used random-effects meta-analysis to estimate average enrollment gaps. 48 studies from 17 countries met the inclusion criteria. The average enrollment rate into health insurance schemes for vulnerable populations was 36% with an inter-quartile range of 26%. On average, across countries, households from the wealthiest subgroup had 61% higher odds (95% CI: 1.49 to 1.73) of insurance enrollment than households in the poorest group in the same country. Similarly, the most educated groups had 64% (95% CI: 1.32 to 1.95) higher odds of enrollment than the least educated groups. The results of this study show that despite major efforts by governments, health insurance schemes in low-and middle-income countries are generally not reaching the targeted underserved populations and predominantly supporting better-off population groups. Current health insurance designs should be carefully scrutinized, and the extent to which health insurance can be used to support the most vulnerable populations carefully re-assessed by countries, which are aiming to use health insurance schemes as means to reach their UHC goals. Furthermore, studies exploring best practices to include vulnerable groups in health insurance schemes are needed. Not available
Tài liệu tham khảo
McIntyre D, Garshong B, Mtei G, Meheus F, Thiede M, Akazili J, et al. Beyond fragmentation and towards universal coverage: insights from Ghana, South Africa and the United Republic of Tanzania. Bull World Health Organ. 2008;86(11):871–6.
McIntyre D, Obse AG, Barasa EW, Ataguba JE: Challenges in Financing Universal Health Coverage in Sub-Saharan Africa. In.: Oxford University Press; 2018.
Kutzin J, Yip W, Cashin C: Alternative Financing Strategies for Universal Health Coverage. In: World Scientific Handbook of Global Health Economics and Public Policy. edn.: 267-309.
Carrin G, Waelkens MP, Criel B. Community-based health insurance in developing countries: a study of its contribution to the performance of health financing systems. Trop Med Int Health. 2005;10(8):799–811.
Yazbeck AS, Savedoff WD, Hsiao WC, Kutzin J, Soucat A, Tandon A, et al. The Case Against Labor-Tax-Financed Social Health Insurance For Low- And Low-Middle-Income Countries. Health Aff (Millwood). 2020;39(5):892–7.
Informality and Poverty in Zambia: Findings from the 2015 Living Conditions and Monitoring Survey, October 2018. In. Geneva: International Labor Office; 2019.
Government of Zambia: The National Health Insurance Act 2018. In., vol. Acts of Parliament (Post. Lusaka. Zambia: Government of Zambia; 1997. p. 2018.
Dmytraczenko TA. Gisele: Health care for all: toward universal health coverage and equity in Latin America and the Caribbean: evidence from selected countries. Washington, DC: World Bank; 2015.
World Health Organization: Global Spending on Health: A World in Transition. In. Geneva, Switzerland World Health Organization; 2019.
Erlangga D, Suhrcke M, Ali S, Bloor K. The impact of public health insurance on health care utilisation, financial protection and health status in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic review. PLoS One. 2019;14(8):e0219731.
Acharya A, Vellakkal S, Taylor F, Masset E, Satija A, Burke M, Ebrahim S: Impact of national health insurance for the poor and the informal sector in low- and middle-income countries: a systematic review; 2012.
Adebayo EF, Uthman OA, Wiysonge CS, Stern EA, Lamont KT, Ataguba JE: A systematic review of factors that affect uptake of community-based health insurance in low-income and middle-income countries. BMC health services research 2015, 15(1):543-543.
Lu C, Chin B, Lewandowski JL, Basinga P, Hirschhorn LR, Hill K, et al. Towards universal health coverage: an evaluation of Rwanda Mutuelles in its first eight years. PloS one. 2012;7(6):1–16.
Spaan E, Mathijssen J, Tromp N, McBain F, ten Have A, Baltussen R. The impact of health insurance in Africa and Asia: a systematic review. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 2012;90(9):685–92.
Wiysonge CS, Paulsen E, Lewin S, Ciapponi A, Herrera CA, Opiyo N, Pantoja T, Rada G, Oxman AD: Financial arrangements for health systems in low-income countries: an overview of systematic reviews. The Cochrane database of systematic reviews 2017, 9:Cd011084.
Wagstaff A, Pradhan M: Health insurance impacts on health and nonmedical consumption in a developing country : Health insurance impacts on health and non-medical consumption in a developing country. In: Policy, Research working paper ; no WPS 3563. Washington, DC: World Bank Group; 2005.
Wagstaff A. Social health insurance reexamined. Health economics. 2010;19(5):503–17.
Fenny AP, Yates R, Thompson R. Social health insurance schemes in Africa leave out the poor. International Health. 2018;10(1):1–3.
Country classification [https://datahelpdesk.worldbank.org/knowledgebase/articles/906519-world-bank-country-and-lending-groups]
[https://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health-topics/study-quality-assessment-tools]
Parmar D, Williams G, Dkhimi F, Ndiaye A, Asante FA, Arhinful DK, et al. Enrolment of older people in social health protection programs in West Africa--does social exclusion play a part? Social science & medicine. 1982;2014(119):36–44.
Mahmood SS, Hanifi SMA, Mia MN, Chowdhury AH, Rahman M, Iqbal M, Bhuiya A: Who enrols in voluntary micro health insurance schemes in low-resource settings? Experience from a rural area in Bangladesh. Global Health Action 2018, 11(1):1-10.
Sarker AR, Sultana M, Mahumud RA, Ahmed S, Islam Z, Morton A, et al. Determinants of enrollment of informal sector workers in cooperative based health scheme in Bangladesh. PLOS ONE. 2017;12(7):1–12.
Cofie P, De Allegri M, Kouyaté B, Sauerborn R. Effects of information, education, and communication campaign on a community-based health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso. Global health action. 2013;6(1):1–12.
Parmar D, De Allegri M, Savadogo G, Sauerborn R. Do community-based health insurance schemes fulfil the promise of equity? A study from Burkina Faso. HEALTH POLICY AND PLANNING. 2014;29(1):76–84.
Oraro T, Ngube N, Atohmbom GY, Srivastava S, Wyss K. The influence of gender and household headship on voluntary health insurance: the case of North-West Cameroon. Health Policy and Planning. 2018;33(2):163–70.
Jin Y, Hou Z, Zhang D. Determinants of Health Insurance Coverage among People Aged 45 and over in China: Who Buys Public, Private and Multiple Insurance. PLOS ONE. 2016;11(8):1–15.
Ruiz Gomez F, Zapata Jaramillo T, Garavito Beltran L. Colombian health care system: results on equity for five health dimensions, 2003-2008. Rev Panam Salud Publuca. 2013;33(2):107–99.
Fenny AP. Live to 70 Years and Older or Suffer in Silence: Understanding Health Insurance Status Among the Elderly Under the NHIS in Ghana. Journal of aging & social policy. 2017;29(4):352–70.
Akazili J, Welaga P, Bawah A, Achana FS, Oduro A, Awoonor-Williams JK, et al. Is Ghana's pro-poor health insurance scheme really for the poor? Evidence from Northern Ghana. BMC Health Services Research. 2014;14(637):1–9.
Dixon J, … EYTE, Planning, Undefined: Ghana's National Health Insurance Scheme: helping the poor or leaving them behind? journalssagepubcom 2011.
Dixon J, Luginaah I: Determinants of Health Insurance Enrolment in Ghana' s Upper West Region. In.; 2014.
Amo T. The National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) in the Dormaa Municipality, Ghana: why some residents remain uninsured? Global journal of health science. 2014;6(3):82–9.
Kotoh AMAM, … SVdGfei, Undefined, Van der Geest S: Why are the poor less covered in Ghana's national health insurance? A critical analysis of policy and practice. equityhealthjbiomedcentralcom 2016, 15(1):34-46.
Jehu-Appiah C, Aryeetey G, Spaan E, de Hoop T, Agyepong I, Baltussen R. Equity aspects of the National Health Insurance Scheme in Ghana: Who is enrolling, who is not and why? SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE. 2011;72(2):157–65.
Duku SKOSKO, van Dullemen CE, Fenenga C. Does health insurance premium exemption policy for older people increase access to health care? Evidence from Ghana. JOURNAL OF AGING & SOCIAL POLICY. 2015;27(4):331–47.
Kusi A, Fenny A, Arhinful DK, Asante FA, Parmar D. Determinants of enrolment in the NHIS for women in Ghana – a cross sectional study. International Journal of Social Economics. 2018;45(9):1318–34.
Kumi-Kyereme A, Amo-Adjei J. Health JA-A: Effects of spatial location and household wealth on health insurance subscription among women in Ghana. BMC Health Services Research. 2013;13(1):221–9.
Amu H, Dickson KS. Health insurance subscription among women in reproductive age in Ghana: do socio-demographics matter? Health Economics Review. 2016;6(24):1–8.
Sarpong N, Loag W, Fobil J, Meyer CG, Adu-Sarkodie Y, May J, Schwarz NG: National health insurance coverage and socio-economic status in a rural district of Ghana. Tropical Medicine and International Health 2010.
Seddoh A, Sataru F. Mundane? Demographic characteristics as predictors of enrolment onto the National Health Insurance Scheme in two districts of Ghana. BMC Health Services Research. 2018;18(1):330–6.
Van der Wielen N, Channon AA, Falkingham J. Universal health coverage in the context of population ageing: What determines health insurance enrolment in rural Ghana? BMC Public Health. 2018;18(1):657–70.
Khalid M. Three Essays on the Informal Sector: University of Manitoba; 2017.
Boateng D, Awunyor-Vitor D. Health insurance in Ghana: evaluation of policy holders' perceptions and factors influencing policy renewal in the Volta region. International journal for equity in health. 2013;12(50):1–10.
Manortey S, VanDerslice J, Alder S, Henry KA, Crookston B, Dickerson T, et al. Spatial Analysis of Factors Associated with Household Subscription to the National Health Insurance Scheme in Rural Ghana. Journal of public health in Africa. 2014;5(1):353–61.
van der Wielen N, Channon AA, Falkingham J. Does insurance enrolment increase healthcare utilisation among rural-dwelling older adults? Evidence from the National Health Insurance Scheme in Ghana. BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH. 2018;3(1):1–9.
Kuuire VZ, Tenkorang EY, Rishworth A, Luginaah I, Yawson AE. Is the Pro-Poor Premium Exemption Policy of Ghana's NHIS Reducing Disparities Among the Elderly? POPULATION RESEARCH AND POLICY REVIEW. 2017;36(2):231–49.
Parmar D, Williams G, Dkhimi F, Ndiaye A, Asante FA, Arhinful DK, et al. Enrolment of older people in social health protection programs in West Africa--does social exclusion play a part? Social Science and Medicine. 2014;119:36–44.
Panda P, Chakraborty A, Dror DM, Bedi AS: Enrollment in Community-Based Health Insurance Schemes in Rural Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, India. Health Policy and Planning 2014, 29(8):960-974.
Ghosh S: Publicly-Financed Health Insurance for the Poor Understanding RSBY in Maharashtra. 2014, 46.
Nosratnejad S, Rashidian A, Mehrara M, Jafari N, Moeeni M, Babamohamadi H. Factors Influencing Basic and Complementary Health Insurance Purchasing Decisions in Iran: Analysis of Data From a National Survey. WORLD MEDICAL & HEALTH POLICY. 2016;8(2):179–96.
Oraro T, Wyss K: How does membership in local savings groups influence the determinants of national health insurance demand? A cross-sectional study in Kisumu, Kenya. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR EQUITY IN HEALTH 2018, 17(1):170-170.
Alkenbrack S, Jacobs B, Lindelow M: Achieving universal health coverage through voluntary insurance: what can we learn from the experience of Lao PDR? BMC health services research 2013, 13(1):521-521.
Adhikari N, Wagle RR, Adhikari DR, Thapa P, Adhikari M. Factors Affecting Enrolment in the Community Based Health Insurance Scheme of Chandranigahapur Hospital of Rautahat District. Journal of Nepal Health Research Council. 2019;16(41):378–84.
Finnoff C. Gendered Vulnerabilities after Genocide: Three Essays on Post-conflict Rwanda: University of Massachusetts; 2010.
Mladovsky P, Soors W, Ndiaye P, Ndiaye A, Criel B. Can social capital help explain enrolment (or lack thereof) in community-based health insurance? Results of an exploratory mixed methods study from Senegal. Social science & medicine. 1982;2014(101):18–27.
Goudge J, Alaba OA, Govender V, Harris B, Nxumalo N, Chersich MF. Social health insurance contributes to universal coverage in South Africa, but generates inequities:a survey among members of a government employee insurance scheme. International journal for Equity in Health. 2018;17(1):1–13.
Govender V, Chersich MF, Harris B, Alaba O, Ataguba JE, Nxumalo N, et al. Moving towards universal coverage in South Africa? Lessons from a voluntary government insurance scheme. Global Health Action. 2013;6(1):109–19.
Bendig M, Arun T. Enrolment in Micro Life and Health Insurance: Evidences from Sri Lanka. Econstor. 2011;5427:1–30.
Macha J, Kuwawenaruwa A, Makawia S, Mtei G, Borghi J. Determinants of community health fund membership in Tanzania: a mixed methods analysis. BMC health services research. 2014;14(1):538–49.
Nguyen THT-H, Leung S. Dynamics of Health Insurance Enrollment in Vietnam, 2004-2006. Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy. 2013;18(4):594–614.
Nguyen H, Knowles J. Demand for voluntary health insurance in developing countries: The case of Vietnam's school-age children and adolescent student health insurance program. SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE. 2010;71(12):2074–82.
Montenegro Torres FBA, Oscar: Colombia Case Study : The Subsidized Regime of Colombia’s National Health Insurance System. In., vol. UNICO Studies Series;No. 15. Washington, DC.: World Bank; 2013.
Barasa E, Kazungu J, Nguhiu P, Ravishankar N. Examining the level and inequality in health insurance coverage in 36 sub-Saharan African countries. BMJ Global Health. 2021;6(4):e004712.
Bossert T, Blanchet N, Sheetz S, Pinto D, Cali J, Cuevas RP. Comparative Review of Health System Integration in Selected Countries in Latin America In. Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank; 2014.
El-Sayed AM, Vail D, Kruk ME. Ineffective insurance in lower and middle income countries is an obstacle to universal health coverage. J Glob Health. 2018;8(2):020402.
Aryeetey GC, Jehu-Appiah C, Spaan E, D’Exelle B, Agyepong I, Baltussen R: Identification of poor households for premium exemptions in Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme: empirical analysis of three strategies. 2010, 15(12):1544-1552.
Marwa B, Njau B, Kessy J, Mushi D. Feasibility of introducing compulsory community health fund in low resource countries: views from the communities in Liwale district of Tanzania. BMC Health Services Research. 2013;13(1):298.
Umeh CA. Identifying the poor for premium exemption: a critical step towards universal health coverage in Sub-Saharan Africa. Global Health Research and Policy. 2017;2(1):2.
Salari P, Akweongo P, Aikins M, Tediosi F. Determinants of health insurance enrolment in Ghana: evidence from three national household surveys. Health Policy and Planning. 2019;34(8):582–94.
Maluka SO: Why are pro-poor exemption policies in Tanzania better implemented in some districts than in others? International journal for equity in health 2013, 12:80-80.
Sood N, Wagner Z: Social health insurance for the poor: lessons from a health insurance programme in Karnataka, India, BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH 2018, 3(1):e000582-e000582.
O'Donnell O. Access to health care in developing countries: breaking down demand side barriers. Cadernos de Saúde Pública. 2007;23:2820–34.
Nsiah-Boateng E, Nonvignon J, Aryeetey GC, Salari P, Tediosi F, Akweongo P, Aikins M: Sociodemographic determinants of health insurance enrolment and dropout in urban district of Ghana: a cross-sectional study. Health economics review 2019, 9(1):23-23.