The Effect of Friendly Persuasion and Gender on Tax Comliance Behavior

Journal of Business Ethics - 2003
Janne Chung1, Vaswanath Umashanker Trivedi1
1Schulich School of Business, York University, Toronto, Canada

Tóm tắt

Friendly persuasion, in contrast to deterrent measures like tax audits and penalties on underreported taxes, is a positive and possibly a cost effective method of increasing taxpayer compliance. However, prior studies have failed to show that friendly persuasion has a significant impact on compliance (Blumenthal et al., 2001; McGraw and Scholz, 1991). In our study, in contrast to prior studies, we examine the impact of generating and reading reasons supporting compliance as friendly persuasion on individuals' income reporting behavior as well as control for gender effects. Specifically, we predict an interaction effect between friendly persuasion and gender on compliance behavior. We carried out a 2 (friendly persuasion and control) × 2 (men and women) full factorial experiment, where participants earned $30 by completing two questionnaires. Participants in the friendly persuasion group were required first to generate and second to read a list of reasons why they should comply fully. Afterwards, participants in both groups were asked to report the income they earned and pay tax on the reported income. The results show a significant main effect for gender as well as a significant interaction effect between gender and friendly persuasion on income reported. Women in the friendly persuasion group reported significantly higher income compared to men in that group. Other comparisons were not significant. Policy implications for increasing taxpayers' ethics and compliance are highlighted.

Từ khóa


Tài liệu tham khảo

Alm, J.: 1991, 'A Perspective on the Experimental Analysis of Taxpayer Reporting', The Accounting Review 66(3), 577-594.

Beron, K. J., H. V. Tauchen and A. D. Witte: 1992, 'The Effect of Audits and Socioeconomic Variables on Compliance', in Joel Slemrod (ed.), Why People Pay Taxes: Tax Compliance and Enforcement (The University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor), pp. 67-89.

Blumenthal, M., C. Christian and J. Slemrod: 2001, 'Do Normative Appeals Affect Tax Compliance? Evidence from a Controlled Experiment in Minnesota', National Tax Journal 54(1), 125-138.

Burkhardt, M. E.: 1994, 'Social Interaction Effects Following a Technological Change: A Longitudinal Investigation', Academy of Management Journal 37(4), 869-898.

Chodorow, N.: 1978, The Reproduction of Mothering (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).

Chung, J. and G. S. Monroe: 2001, 'A Research Note on the Effects of Gender and Task Complexity on an Audit Judgment', Behavioral Research in Accounting 13, 111-125.

Chung, J. and G. S. Monroe: 2003, 'Exploring Social Desirability Bias', Journal of Business Ethics (in press).

Cialdini, R. B.: 1989, 'Social Motivations to Comply: Norms, Values and Principles', in J. A. Roth and 144 Janne Chung and Viswanath Umashanker Trivedi J. T. Scholz (eds.), Taxpayer Compliance, Vol. 2, Social Science Perspectives (University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia), pp. 220-227.

Davenport, D. S. and J. M. Yurich: 1991, 'Multicultural Gender Issues', Journal of Counseling & Development 70 (September/October), 64-71.

Dezhbakhsh, H. and P. H. Rubin: 1998, 'Lives Saved or Lives Lost? The Effects of Concealed-Handguns Laws on Crime', AEA Papers and Proceedings 88 (2), 468-474.

Hill, R. and M. Kabir: 1996, 'Tax Rates, the Tax Mix, and the Growth of the Underground Economy in Canada: What Can We Infer', Canadian Tax Journal 44(6), 1552-1583.

Hoch, S.: 1984, 'Availability and Inference in Predictive Judgment', Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 10, 649-662.

Jackson, B. R. and V. C. Milliron: 1986, 'Tax Compliance Research: Findings, Problems, and Prospects', Journal of Accounting Literature 5, 125-161.

Kaplan, S. E., K. J. Newberry and P. M. J. Reckers: 1997, 'The Effect of Moral Reasoning and Educational Communication on Tax Evasion Intentions', The Journal of the American Taxation Association 19(2), 38-54.

Kinsey, K. A.: 1992, 'Deterrence and Alienation Effects of IRS Enforcement: An Analysis of Survey Data', in Joel Slemrod (ed.), Why People Pay Taxes: Tax Compliance and Enforcement (The University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor), pp. 259-285.

Koonce, L. 1992: 'Explanation and Counterexplanation During Audit Analytical Review', The Accounting Review 67(1), 59-76.

Koriat, A., S. Lichtenstein and P. Fischhoff: 1980, 'Reasons for Confidence', Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 6, 107-118.

McGraw, K. M. and J. T. Scholz: 1991, 'Appeals to Civic Virtue versus Attention to Self-Interest: Effects on Tax Compliance', Law and Society Review 23(2), 209-240.

Rest, J. R.: 1984, 'The Major Components of Morality', in W. L. Jurtines and J. L. Gewirtz (eds.), Morality, Moral Behavior, and Moral Development (Wiley, New York).

Roth, J. A., J. T. Scholz and A. D. Witte: 1989, Taxpayer Compliance. Volume I: An agenda for Research (University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia).

Scholz, J. T. and N. Pinney: 1995, 'Duty, Fear, and Tax Compliance: The Heuristic Basis of Citizenship Behavior', American Journal of Political Science 39(2), 490-512.

Schwartz, R. and S. Orleans: 1967, 'On Legal Sanctions', University of Chicago Law Review 34, 274-300.

Shavit, T., D. Sonsino and U. Benzion: 2001, 'A Comparative Study of Lotteries-Evaluation in Class and on the Web', Journal of Economic Psychology 22(4), 483-491.

Sirsi, A. K., J. C. Ward and P. H. Reingen: 1996, 'Microcultural Analysis of Variation in Sharing of Causal Reasoning about Behavior', Journal of Consumer Research 22, 345-372.

Smith, K. W.: 1992, 'Reciprocity and Fairness: Positive Incentives for Tax Compliance', in Joel Slemrod (ed.), Why People Pay Taxes: Tax Compliance and Enforcement (The University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor), pp. 223-250.

Spicer, M. W. and R. E. Hero: 1985, 'Tax Evasion and Heuristics', Journal of Public Economics 26, 263-267.

Steenbergen, M. R., K. M. McGraw and J. T. Scholz: 1992, 'Taxpayer Adaptation to the 1986 Tax Reform Act: Do New Tax Laws Affect the Way Taxpayers Think about Taxes', in Joel Slemrod (ed.), Why People Pay Taxes: Tax Compliance and Enforcement (The University of Michigan Press Ann Arbor), pp. 9-37.

Tabachnick, B. and L. Fidell: 1996, Using Multivariate Statistics (Harper Collins College Publishers, New York, NY).

Thông tin
Thông tin xuất bản

Journal of Business Ethics

Thông tin tác giả